Atomic Structure
1. Subatomic Particles
Subatomic particles = the particles inside an atom: protons, electrons, neutrons.
| Relative charge | Relative mass | |
|---|---|---|
| proton | +1 | 1 |
| neutron | 0 | 1 |
| electron | −1 | 11840 ≈ 0 |
Electron mass: for all practical purposes (weighing scale) it is 0, but the true value is 1/1840 of a proton — use the real number in calculations (e.g. electron velocity in Physics), otherwise the calculation dies at zero.
Behaviour in an electric field
- Opposite charges attract: electrons → positive plate, protons → negative plate.
- Neutrons have no charge ⇒ undeflected (straight).
- Electron path is drawn shorter / more curved — it hits the plate first.
electron: Qm = −11/1840 → huge | proton: +11 = 1 | neutron: 01 = 0
Magnitude of charge is same for e⁻ and p⁺ (1 each) — the difference is only the tiny mass of the electron ("less mass" / larger Q/m). Order: electrons > protons > neutrons (0).
Possible exam twist: a mixed beam of e⁻, p⁺, n → "separate them": pass through an electric field (one plate +, one −) and they split into 3 beams by themselves.
Electronic structure at O-level — the Bohr model
Sodium (Na): 11 protons, neutrons = 23 − 11 = 12 (from the periodic table: atomic no. 11, mass no. 23). Electrons = 11 → shells fill 2, 8, 1 (draw crosses or dots).
This "shells only" model is called the Bohr model (Niels Bohr — his work reappears in A2 Physics: Quantum Physics). It worked well: ionic bonding (Na loses its 1 valence e⁻), octets, 11+ nucleus with 11 e⁻…
Sir's aside: "What you learnt earlier was right for that time — you'd have blown a fuse if we taught everything at once. Humanity progressed the same way: new phenomena appeared, the old model couldn't explain them, so a better one was built."
2. The Quantum Model
Sir: "This slide is for understanding, not rote-learning. Pointers can appear as MCQs, but the periodic-table hack does the real work."
- Electrons are arranged in shells, n = 1, 2, 3 … — n = principal quantum number (Bohr said shells too — not wrong, just incomplete).
- Shells increase in energy as n increases (a few exceptions — e.g. 4s vs 3d, see later).
- Each shell has subshells — the number of subshells = its principal quantum number (n = 1 → 1, n = 2 → 2 …). ← new in the quantum model (Bohr stopped at shells).
- Subshells are named s, p, d, f — always in that order (never 1, 2, 3, 4).
- Each subshell has one or more orbitals = little "boxes" where the electrons actually sit: s → 1, p → 3, d → 5, f → 7 (odd numbers going up).
| Shell | No. of subshells | Names of subshells | Orbitals present |
|---|---|---|---|
| n = 1 | 1 | 1s | 1s |
| n = 2 | 2 | 2s, 2p | 2s, 2px, 2py, 2pz |
| n = 3 | 3 | 3s, 3p, 3d | 3s, 3px, 3py, 3pz, (5 × 3d) |
| n = 4 | 4 | 4s, 4p, 4d, 4f | 4s, 4px, 4py, 4pz, (5 × 4d), (7 × 4f) |
Only need: s has just "s"; p → px, py, pz; d → just say "5 × 3d" (individual d-orbital names are A2). The 1s / 2s "orbital names" are given only for consistency — nobody asks the table.
Electron spin & filling rules
- Electrons have a property called spin: spin up ↑ or spin down ↓ (drawn with a full or half arrowhead).
- Electrons fill orbitals in order of increasing energy — work it out from the periodic table.
- An orbital holds a maximum of 2 electrons; if 2, they must have opposite spin (↑↓ — "anti-parallel").
- Orbitals of equal energy (e.g. the three 2p) → each gets 1 electron first, and only then start pairing up (Hund).
3. The Periodic-Table Hack
The periodic table tells you the whole configuration. Split it into blocks named after the subshell being filled:
- s-block = groups 1 & 2 (also H and He). p-block = groups 13–18 (B → Ne and downwards). d-block = groups 3–12 = transition metals. f-block = the two rows below → ignore.
- From now on write the groups as 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18 — not 3,4,5,6,7,8 (that's O-level!).
- The period number gives the shell number for s & p blocks: e.g. Mg is in period 3 → 3s. Chlorine: period 3, 5th p-box → 3p⁵.
(f-block takes the number 2 periods before.)
Mg → 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² · Cl → 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p⁵ · Ti → …3p⁶ 4s² 3d²
Write 4s before 3d (as the table gives it). Some teachers write 3d before 4s — also accepted, but sir's way reduces mistakes and shows the filling order (no marks lost either way).
4. Electronic Configuration (Z = 1 – 30)
Method: find the element on the table → count back from the start, filling every earlier subshell completely → last one = leftover electrons. For the arrangement (box diagram) draw a box for each orbital (s = 1 box, p = 3 joined, d = 5 joined) and fill: singly first, then pair.
Period 1 & 2 (H → Ne)
Notes: H → 1s¹ (↑); He → 1s² (↑↓ — opposite spins). B is the first p-electron; C, N put 1 electron in each 2p box; O is the first that must pair (2p⁴ = ↑↓ ↑ ↑); F = ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑; Ne completes 2p⁶.
Period 3 & K, Ca (Na → Ca)
Transition metals (Sc → Zn)
Sir: d-block boxes — draw 5 joined boxes for d; put 1 electron in each first (Sc → Mn), only then pair (Fe onwards). Fe: 3d⁶ = ↑↓ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑; Ni: 3d⁸ = ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑ ↑; Zn: five ↑↓ boxes.
5. Shorthand Configuration & Anomalies
Shorthand configuration: instead of writing everything, quote the noble gas BEFORE the element in square brackets, then carry on from there.
★ Anomalous configurations of Cr and Cu
Expected (from the table): Cr = …4s² 3d⁴ and Cu = …4s² 3d⁹. Reality: one electron moves from 4s to 3d.
Why is 4s filled before 3d?
- 4s is LOWER in energy than 3d (when the atom is being built) — it sits closer to the nucleus, so it is easier to put an electron in it ⇒ 4s fills first (K, Ca), then 3d (Sc → Zn).
- Bohr's "fill shell by shell" (all of shell 3 before shell 4) would predict 3d first — this is one thing the quantum model explains and Bohr cannot.
- Energy order of filling: 1s < 2s < 2p < 3s < 3p < 4s < 3d < 4p …
- Twist: once 4s is filled it goes up above 3d (electrons gained → higher energy). So when transition metals lose electrons, 4s goes first (see ions).
6. Configuration on an Energy Graph
Examiners sometimes ask "show the electrons and relative energies". Students go wrong here because they never practised it. Don't stack the boxes side by side — draw each subshell higher than the previous one (energy on the y-axis), in the same order you wrote the configuration (that already is the energy order, so no extra memorising).
- 1s lowest → then 2s → 2p (3 equal-energy boxes side by side) → 3s → 3p …
- Equal-energy boxes (the three p's, five d's) are drawn at the same height; fill singly first, then pair.
7. Electronic Configuration of Ions
Rule: write the neutral atom first, then remove (positive ion) or add (negative ion) electrons as shown by the charge. Electrons are removed from the highest-energy (outermost) subshell, added to the next available spot.
Note: Na⁺, O²⁻, Ca²⁺, Br⁻ all end at a noble-gas configuration (Ne, Ne, Ar, Kr). Ca²⁺ loses the whole 4s; Br⁻ fills 4p to 4p⁶.
Using shorthand configuration:
8. Shapes of s and p Orbitals
s orbital: a 3-D sphere centred on the nucleus (like a ball extending along x, y and z). 2s and 3s are also spheres — the higher the energy, the bigger the sphere (further from the nucleus).
p orbital: a dumbbell / "infinity sign" (figure of eight) — two lobes, centred on an axis that its subscript names: 2px on the x-axis, 2py on the y-axis, 2pz on the z-axis. All three 2p are identical in shape/size ⇒ equal energy.
Exam link: the "infinity sign" shown in a question = a p orbital (see practice Q1(b)(iii)). "State the number of electrons in all orbitals of this type in F" → F is 1s² 2s² 2p⁵ ⇒ 5 electrons in p orbitals.
9. Past-Paper Practice — Structure & Configuration
Sir: past-paper questions are the real revision — keep your solved topicals and re-read them while revising (the notes cannot hold everything).
Diagram: separate beams of electrons and protons from one source between two vertical plates. (i) Give the charge on each plate. (ii) Draw the path of a beam of neutrons.
(i) electrons (−) are attracted to the left plate ⇒ positive; protons (+) to the right plate ⇒ negative [1]
(ii) neutrons: straight, undeflected line from the source (no charge) [1]
Trap: count orbitals, not subshells! A p subshell = 3 orbitals, d = 5.
| type of orbital | s | p | d |
|---|---|---|---|
| number of orbitals | 4 | 9 | 5 |
Complete the energy-level diagram (2 marks): Si = 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p². Draw boxes in rising order, 4s box left empty, and the two 3p electrons unpaired (↑ ↑ _).
Common mistake: pairing the 3p electrons (↑↓ _ _) — equal-energy boxes fill singly first.
The orbital drawn is a figure-of-eight = p orbital. F (Z = 9) = 1s² 2s² 2p⁵ ⇒ total electrons in p orbitals = 5 electrons.
State, in terms of subatomic particles in the nucleus, what is the same and what differs.
same: proton number | different: neutron number (mass number)
Sir: all three have no electrons (H⁺ = a bare proton) — true, but the question says "in the nucleus", so don't mention electrons or you'd be wrong for that question.
The first ionisation energies of Sc (21) to Cu (29) are very similar. In all of them a 4s electron is lost in the first ionisation. Suggest why the values are very similar.
Use the three factors: nuclear charge, shielding, atomic radius. Reason by elimination (sir's working): nuclear charge increases (21 → 29). If shielding decreased or stayed constant, the pull on the 4s electron (and so the IE) would rise a lot — but the IEs are "very similar" ⇒ shielding must also increase, cancelling the extra nuclear charge.
Why does shielding increase? The 4s² is already filled; each new electron goes into the 3d, which is lower in energy / inner ⇒ the 3d subshell shields the 4s electrons (inner-subshell shielding, not an extra inner shell).
Ge = [Ar] 3d¹⁰ 4s² 4p². Which order are the electrons lost?
Write it in sir's order: [Ar] 4s² 3d¹⁰ 4p² → remove from the end (4p) first, then 4s (never 3d before 4s). Answer: A
P = 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p³. Options: A 1p 2s 2p ✗ (1p doesn't exist) · B 2s 2p 2d ✗ (no 2d) · C 2s 2p 3s ✓ · D 2p 3s 3d ✗ (3d exists but is empty in P).
Answer: C
1 ✓ same electrons · 2 ✓ same neutrons · 3 ✗ protons differ (15 vs 19). Answer: 1 and 2 only.
Valence shell = shell 3 → 3s² + 3p⁴ = 6. 3p⁴ = ↑↓ ↑ ↑ ⇒ 2 unpaired (1s², 2s², 2p⁶ are full).
Only Cr and Cu need you to look at 4s as well. For everything else, just inspect the last subshell.
Answer: B (Ca²⁺)
Sir's "katam-pooti method": when unsure, cross out wrong options — 25% chance becomes 33% after one elimination, 50% after two.
Answer: C (F and Ga)
Tricky one: Ti⁺ — a transition-metal ion loses from 4s first (leaving 4s¹ 3d²), so it has no p electrons.
10. Ionisation Energies
Now the quantum model gets linked to ionisation energies (IE): learn the trends and be able to explain each one — they are the evidence that Bohr's model was not enough. IEs can be 1st, 2nd, 3rd … as many as you like.
Equations (examples — first IE, always one electron off a gaseous atom):
Second ionisation energy: the minimum energy to remove 1 mole of electrons from 1 mole of 1+ gaseous ions to form 1 mole of 2+ gaseous ions. (Equation shows the definition — don't cram it.)
…and so on for other ionisation energies. e.g. 4th IE of Ar: Ar³⁺(g) → Ar⁴⁺(g) + e⁻ · 6th IE of Mg: Mg⁵⁺(g) → Mg⁶⁺(g) + e⁻ (the nth IE starts from the (n−1)+ ion.)
11. Successive Ionisation Energies of One Element
Remove electrons one after another from the same element (1st IE, 2nd IE, 3rd, …). Example: sodium (Bohr structure 2 · 8 · 1) — plot lg IE against number of electrons removed:
Huge jump ⇒ change of shell
After the 1st e⁻ (3rd shell) is gone, you remove electrons from an inner shell, closer to the nucleus ⇒ attracted much more strongly ⇒ far more energy. Another huge jump when you reach the 1st shell (electron 10). So the jump tells you: electron being removed from a shell closer to the nucleus.
3rd shell electron goes first (easy) → then 8 in shell 2 → then 2 in shell 1
Q. Why a slight increase within the same shell?
- ① Charge: as electrons are removed the ion becomes more positive: there are more protons than electrons (e.g. Na⁺ 11p / 10e⁻; Na²⁺ 11p / 9e⁻), so the attraction on each remaining electron is stronger. (Write it as "more protons per electron".)
- ② Repulsion: fewer electrons ⇒ less inter-electron repulsion ⇒ the electrons move closer to the nucleus (radius/shell shrinks) ⇒ the attraction is stronger.
- Hence slightly more energy is needed to remove the next electron.
Finding the group from successive IEs
A huge increase after the nth electron means the first n electrons were valence electrons ⇒ the element has n valence electrons ⇒ it is in group n (for n = 1, 2) or group 10 + n (n = 3 – 8: groups 13 – 18). Use A-level group numbers (3 valence e⁻ = group 13, not 3!).
(a) The first five IEs of element Y (kJ mol⁻¹): 578 · 1817 · 2745 · 3538 · 11 578. To which group does Y belong?
Y: huge increase between the 4th and 5th IE ⇒ 4 valence electrons ⇒ Group 14. (The board note says "between 3rd and 4th" — a slip: the big jump 3538 → 11 578 is 4th → 5th.)
(b) Element A is in the p block; the graph of the first ten successive IEs jumps after the 3rd electron ⇒ group 13. Explanation: there is a huge increase in ionisation energy from the third electron to the fourth electron, meaning A has 3 valence electrons. [2]
12. Trends in First Ionisation Energy
Shielding: the electrons in the inner shells shield the valence electrons from experiencing the full nuclear charge (they repel the outer electron). Each inner-shell electron approximately cancels the effect of 1 proton. (It's not that charge disappears — the outer electron just feels less than the full nucleus.)
① Across a period: first IE generally increases
2) Shielding by inner-shell electrons remains (approximately) constant — the inner shell is the same, valence electrons can't shield each other.
3) So the valence electrons experience a stronger effective charge ⇒ the atomic radius decreases, the force of attraction between nucleus and valence electrons increases ⇒ more energy is required to remove an electron.
Effective charge Li → Ne: +1, +2, +3, +4, +5 … (3−2, 4−2, 5−2 …) — inner shell always 2 e⁻, so shielding can't cancel the growth. All Period-2 elements have the same 2 inner electrons; only nuclear charge rises.
② The two dips inside every period — anomalies
These need the quantum model (subshells, paired electrons) — Bohr can't explain them, which is exactly why the quantum model was developed. Examiners expect you to know them — memorise the reasons.
In Be the electron is removed from the 2s, in B from the 2p. 2s is a lower-energy orbital than 2p (closer to the nucleus, held more tightly), so removing an electron from it is harder ⇒ B has the lower IE.
Same argument: 3s is lower in energy than 3p ⇒ harder to remove from Mg's 3s than Al's 3p.
Rule: every group 2 → group 13 step dips (group 2 ends s², group 13 starts p¹ — an outer p electron is higher in energy / further from nucleus). Don't memorise the answer — change 2s/2p to 3s/3p etc. for the element asked.
N (2p³) has 3 unpaired electrons — none are repelled by another in the same box. O (2p⁴) has one paired electron: two electrons in the same small box already repel each other, so it is easier to remove a paired electron than an unpaired one ⇒ O has lower IE.
P 3p³ (3 unpaired) → S 3p⁴ (2 unpaired + 1 pair): same explanation. Group 15 always ends p³ (half-filled), group 16 always p⁴.
③ Down a group: first IE decreases
e.g. He > Ne > Ar > Kr > Xe (group 18); Li > Na > K > Rb (group 1). No anomalies — a smooth downward trend.
3) Atomic radius increases (more shells) ⇒ valence electron further from nucleus ⇒ pulled less strongly ⇒ easier to remove ⇒ first IE decreases.
Effective charge check: Li 3 − 2 = +1; Na 11 − 10 = +1 — same. So the deciding factor is atomic radius (3rd shell vs 2nd shell).
④ Noble gas → next group 1: big drop
Sketching the period-3 graph (sir wants the "general shape")
- Ne (top) → huge dip to Na → ↑ Mg → dip at Al (group 13; still above Na!) → ↑ Si → ↑ P (group 15) → dip at S (group 16; not below Si / group 14) → ↑ Cl → Ar (highest).
- Your sketch needn't be perfect, but the relative positions matter (Al > Na, S > Si, Ar highest). Exam questions on this ask about period 3.
Why not a straight line? A straight line can be extended until radius = 0 at some atomic number — impossible. The curve levels off horizontally on the right and (like a reciprocal) never reaches zero.
13. Past-Paper Practice — Ionisation Energy
Sir: "The periodic table is your best friend, and you must have the general trend in your head — many MCQs are solved from that alone."
Trap: "consecutive proton numbers" ≠ "across a period"! Check the table: Rn is group 18 (end of period 6) → Fr (group 1, period 7) → Ra (group 2).
Least endothermic = smallest IE = Fr; then Ra; largest = Rn (noble gas).
Answer: A (Fr, Ra, Rn)
Check: 1 mole of electrons removed, from a 1+ ion, all in gaseous state.
Negative species already repel their outer electron ⇒ easy to remove (Cl⁻ ✗ and F⁻ ✗). A positive ion holds its electrons tightly ⇒ hardest: K⁺ vs Na⁺ (both 1+). Na⁺ and K⁺ have the same charge, so compare radius: Na⁺ (2 filled shells) is smaller than K⁺ (3 filled shells) ⇒ attraction to the nucleus is stronger ⇒ hardest.
(Shielding and nuclear charge both increase down the group and cancel — so use atomic radius as the deciding factor.) Answer: D (Na⁺)
Pattern: 1st element mid-height, 2nd element highest, 3rd element lowest of all.
A big drop after the highest point ⇒ 2nd element = noble gas (group 18), 3rd = group 1, so the 1st = group 17. Group 17 among the options C, N, F, Na ⇒ F (C).
Other places a dip occurs are ruled out: group 2 → 13 dip (can't fall below group 1) and group 15 → 16 dip (can't fall below group 14) don't match this "highest then lowest" picture.
Peaks = noble gases (huge dip follows each). The peaks are B, J, R.
Answer: 1, 2 and 3 are all correct.
Alkali metal = group 1 = the huge dip right after a noble-gas peak. R is the peak (noble gas) ⇒ S (next, huge drop) is group 1. P, Q are before the peak (rising towards group 18), so they are not group 1.
Answer: D (element S)
(i) Define first IE [2] → "The minimum amount of energy required to remove 1 mole of electrons from 1 mole of gaseous atoms to form 1 mole of 1+ charged gaseous ions." (gaseous atoms, not Cl₂.)
(ii) Why is B's first IE much lower than A's? [3] — A = noble gas (end of a period), B = group 1 (start of next):
The electron in B is removed from a higher energy level (new shell). From A to B the nuclear charge increases and so does the shielding, so they cancel each other out. The atomic radius increases (extra shell), so the nucleus pulls the valence electron less strongly ⇒ less energy is needed to remove an electron.
(c)(i) Sketch atomic radius across period 3 [1] → decreasing reciprocal curve (see previous page; not a straight line).
(ii) Explain [3] — the nuclear charge increases while the shielding by inner electrons remains constant across the period. Hence the valence electrons experience a greater effective charge and the atomic radius decreases.
(a) Define first IE — as above.
(b) Equation with state symbols for the second IE of sodium:
Common error: putting the electron on the wrong side or forgetting the 1+ ion; e⁻ has no state symbol.
(c) Graph: mark crosses for Na, P, S on the given grid; join. Na lower than Mg (group 1 → 2 up); Al dips but not below Na; P higher than Si (group 14 → 15 up); S dips below P but not below Si; then Cl, Ar. Examiner wants approximate positions only.
(ii) Why first IE generally increases from Na to Ar
Nuclear charge increases but shielding by inner-shell electrons remains constant. Therefore the valence electrons feel a stronger pull, the atomic radius decreases and more energy is required to remove an electron.
(iii) Why is first IE of Al less than Mg? (Mg: 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s²; Al: 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p¹)
In Mg the electron is removed from a 3s orbital, which is lower in energy and closer to the nucleus than the 3p orbital from which the electron of Al is removed. So more energy is required to remove an electron from Mg.
Lowest → highest: S⁻ < S < S⁺
Reasoning: positive species pull electrons harder (fewer electrons, smaller radius, more protons per electron); negative species repel. S⁺ also has no paired electrons (harder), S⁻ has the biggest radius and repulsion (easiest).
14. Exam Technique & Study Advice
- Have the periodic table open — every config, ion, IE question starts there.
- Write full words ("third and fourth ionisation energy", "electrons") — no abbreviations/short forms.
- Use A-level group numbers (13 not 3; 14 not 4; 18 or 0).
- IE / equation questions: state symbols, gaseous atoms (Cl not Cl₂), one electron, always positive ion.
- Explaining a trend? Nuclear charge → shielding → atomic radius → conclusion (all three, in that order).
- Config: write like the table (4s before 3d), fill p/d boxes singly first, watch Cr & Cu, remember d takes previous period, and TM ions lose 4s first.
- MCQ: cross out wrong options one by one — every elimination raises your odds.
- Keep answers within the lines; write close to the ruled line (scan cuts margin); cross out neatly, write above if no extra sheet.
- Past papers are the key to A levels: keep solved topicals, re-read them when revising, then attempt fresh ones — you learn what the examiner expects.
15. Full Chapter Cheat-Sheet
- p⁺ (+1, 1) · n (0, 1) · e⁻ (−1, 1/1840). Field: e⁻ → + plate (most), p⁺ → − plate, n straight; more charge/mass ratio ⇒ more deflection.
- Bohr = shells only (2, 8, 1…). Quantum = shells (n) ⊃ subshells (n of them: s p d f) ⊃ orbitals (s 1, p 3, d 5, f 7) ⊃ ≤ 2 e⁻ (opposite spins).
- Fill lowest energy first; equal-energy orbitals singly first (↑ ↑ ↑ then pair). Periodic-table blocks: s (1, 2 + H, He), p (13–18), d (3–12, uses n − 1).
- Cr = [Ar] 4s¹ 3d⁵ · Cu = [Ar] 4s¹ 3d¹⁰ (half/full d is more stable). 4s is lower than 3d when filling.
- Shorthand = nearest noble gas behind the element in [ ], only when asked.
- Ions: remove from the outermost/highest-energy (p, then s); transition metals: 4s first, then 3d. Negative ions: add into next spot. Ge⁴⁺: 4p, 4p, 4s, 4s.
- s orbital = sphere (bigger = higher energy); p = dumbbell on x, y or z axis (2px = 2py = 2pz energy; 3p larger).
- 1st IE: min. energy to remove 1 mol e⁻ from 1 mol gaseous atoms → 1 mol 1+ gaseous ions. Equation: X(g) → X⁺(g) + e⁻. 2nd IE: X⁺(g) → X²⁺(g) + e⁻. Always endothermic.
- Successive IEs: huge jump = the next electron comes from a shell closer to the nucleus → number of electrons removed before the jump = valence electrons = group. Slight rise inside a shell: more p per e⁻ + less repulsion → smaller radius.
- Across a period ↑: nuclear charge ↑, shielding constant, radius ↓, stronger pull. Down a group ↓: nuclear charge ↑ & shielding ↑ cancel, radius ↑, weaker pull. Noble gas → group 1: big drop (new shell).
- Dips: group 2 → 13 (s → p: p higher in energy, easier) · group 15 → 16 (paired electron repulsion: paired e⁻ easier to remove).
- Shape of period-3 graph: Na low, Mg ↑, Al ↓ (above Na), Si ↑, P ↑, S ↓ (above Si), Cl ↑, Ar highest. Atomic radius across period: decreasing reciprocal curve.
- Negative species easier to ionise (repulsion, larger radius); positive harder. Same charge: smaller radius = harder.
- IE variation across the table = evidence for the quantum model (Bohr can't explain the dips).