Inflation
1. What is Inflation? & Aggregate Demand
Inflation → Prices ↑
Definition: a persistent and sustained increase in the general price level over a given period of time.
★ Aggregate Demand (AD)
Definition: the total demand of the whole economy e.g. the Pakistan economy.
Balance of Trade (BOT) = X − M
(export revenue − import expenditure)
- BOT surplus → XTR > MTE
- BOT deficit → MTE > XTR
The 5 components — how each one raises AD
1) Consumption expenditure — done by consumers, generates income, affects AD!!
Situation: Recession → income ↓. Policy: Income tax ↓ → disposable income ↑ → purchasing power ↑ → consumption ↑ → AD ↑
2) Investment expenditure — done by producers/firms, generates income, affects AD!!
Yr 1: interest rate 20% → Yr 2: interest rate 10% (r ↓). Then two groups react:
| Savers | Borrowers |
|---|---|
| save ↓ (rate of return ↓) | borrow ↑ (cost of borrowing ↓) |
| spend ↑ → C ↑ | reinvestment ↑ → I ↑ |
| AD ↑ | AD ↑ |
3) Government expenditure — done by government, generates income, affects AD!!
Roads ↑ → Jobs ↑ → Income ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑
4) Export revenue (XTR) — Policy: subsidy to domestic producers
X price ↓ → X qty ↑ → XTR ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑
5) Import expenditure (MTE) — Policy: tariff (tax on imported goods)
M price ↑ → M qty ↓ → MTE ↓ → people switch to domestic goods → C ↑ → AD ↑
2. Effects of Inflation (#1 – #9)
#1 Unemployment (internal effect)
Inflation → Prices ↑ → Consumption ↓ → AD ↓ → producer gets the signal → production ↓ → demand for labour (DL) ↓ → Unemployment ↑
Producer contracts production and, to maintain profits, lays off some employees.
#2 Balance of Trade deficit (external effect)
Inflation → Prices ↑
Exports: X price ↑ → X qty ↓ → XTR ↓
Relatively (for residents) imports look cheaper: M price ↓ → M qty ↑ → MTE ↑
MTE > XTR ⇒ BOT deficit
Our goods become uncompetitive in the international market. Considering export and import demand are elastic, export revenue falls and import expenditure rises.
#3 Depreciation of the currency (FOREX market)
| Exports side (Pakistan → USA) | Imports side (USA → Pakistan) |
|---|---|
| payments received ↓ | payments made ↑ |
| demand for Rs ↓ | sell / supply of Rs ↑ |
| surplus of Rs | surplus of Rs |
| value of Rs ↓ | value of Rs ↓ |
#4 Effect on Real Income
- Nominal income → before deduction of tax and inflation rate
- Disposable income → after deduction of tax
- Real income → after deduction of tax and inflation rate
#5 Effect on Savers
Day 1: save $100,000 at 20% ⇒ $120,000 after a year. Day 365: inflation turns out to be 30% ⇒ money buys less than before.
At times of inflation saving is discouraged.
#6 Lenders / Borrowers · #7 Menu cost
#6 Lenders & borrowers: it is easier for a borrower to repay during inflation, but when the lender gets the money back it is worth less. Lenders therefore set the interest rate according to the (expected) inflation rate.
Board example: Day 1 inflation expected 5% → loan $100,000 at 10% ⇒ $110,000 back; Day 365 inflation is 20% ⇒ lender loses in real terms.
#7 Menu cost: the price list (e.g. a restaurant menu) must be changed again and again.
Weekly price ↑ (burgers) → input price/cost ↑ → price ↑ → menus must be reprinted → printing cost (menu cost) ↑ → further raises price, at a faster rate.
#8 Shoe-leather cost · #9 Pension / fixed-income earners
#8 Shoe-leather cost: people have to move around (and at different times) to gather savings/investments and re-invest them in line with inflation — this takes time, and meanwhile the value of money keeps falling.
#9 Pension / fixed-income earners: the worst hit — prices rise at a faster rate, purchasing power falls and their (fixed) income is substantially curtailed.
★ Conclusion of Inflation → Evaluation
• Economy open to international trade (income depends on the foreign sector) → external effects hit harder: BOT deficit + depreciation.
• Economy not open (income depends on the domestic sector) → internal effects (unemployment, falling real income…) are more harmful.
So: the AED barely moves (managed/pegged) while the Rs is market-driven ⇒ a floating currency feels inflation more.
3. Causes of Inflation — Cost-Push & Monetary
2) Cost-Push Inflation → reason: AS ↓
Cost ↑ → burden ↑ → derivative AS ↓ → shortage → Prices ↑ → Inflation
Reasons (cost ↑):
- Cost of production ↑
- Imposition of indirect tax
- Removal of subsidy
- Price of raw materials ↑
- Imported inflation
- Wage-price spiral
A decrease in short-run AS from SRAS to SRAS₁ (cost of production ↑) creates a shortage, so the price level rises from P to P₁ (the inflation rate).
Real income falls from Y to Y₁ ⇒ purchasing power ↓. New equilibrium moves e → e₁.
Wage-Price Spiral
Trade union: an organisation of working people who agree to negotiate with the employer on behalf of employees.
| Employee | Employer |
|---|---|
| Reason: inflation → prices ↑ Target: wages ↑ | Reason: inflation → P↑ (productivity asked in return) Condition: wages ↑ ⇒ productivity ↑ |
- On the other side, higher wages = higher worker income = purchasing power ↑ → demand ↑ → shortage → prices ↑ ⇒ demand-pull inflation too.
- If the trade union teams up with the government to push wages up, unemployment follows: higher wages raise cost of production, more labour is supplied but less is demanded.
Imported Inflation
PED of oil: short run → inelastic, long run → elastic.
M price ↑ 50% → M qty ↓ only 10% → MTE ↑ → cost ↑ → AS ↓ → shortage → price ↑ → imported inflation
Imported inflation occurs when an economy imports raw material (inelastic in the short run) from a country that faces inflation — we cannot cut quantity much, so import expenditure rises and so does our cost of production.
For the exporting country (USA): X price ↑ → X qty ↓ → XTR ↓.
3) Monetary Inflation → reason: Money Supply ↑
Money demand: every transaction has an opportunity cost — the money could have been saved and earned interest. So interest rate and quantity demanded of money are negatively related ⇒ downward-sloping MD.
Monetary equilibrium: intersection of money demand and money supply decides the interest rate and quantity of money.
Money supply ↑ and interest rate ↓ (−ve):
| Savers | Borrowers |
|---|---|
| save ↓ (rate of return ↓) | borrow ↑ (cost of borrowing ↓) |
| spend ↑ → C ↑ | reinvestment ↑ → I.E. ↑ |
| AD ↑ | AD ↑ |
producer: production ↑ → DL ↑ → Unemployment ↓
| Short run | Long run |
|---|---|
| Multiplier effect (income, output, employment ↑) → mild inflation: prices ↑ 10%, R.I. ↑ 50% (prices rise slower than real income) | Hyper-inflation: only price level ↑, R.I. constant (–) |
Exchange-rate route (r ↓ ⇒ ER ↓, +ve):
X price ↓, X qty ↑ → XTR ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑ → U ↓ ; M price ↑, M qty ↓ → MTE ↓ ⇒ BOT surplus (XTR > MTE)
Interest rate ↔ exchange rate (+ve): when the interest rate falls, our exports look cheaper → export quantity and revenue ↑; imports look more expensive → import quantity and expenditure ↓ ⇒ balance of trade surplus.
4. Inflation vs Disinflation vs Deflation
| Prices | Meaning | |
|---|---|---|
| Inflation | ↑ | persistent and sustained increase in the general price level over a given period of time |
| Disinflation | ↑ but slower | prices are still increasing but at a decreasing (slower) rate |
| Deflation | ↓ (−ve) | persistent and sustained fall in the general price level over a given period of time |
Teacher's year table (as written on the board):
| Yr1 | Yr2 | Yr3 | Yr4 | Yr5 | Yr6 | Yr7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 102% | 110% | 116% | 112% | 108% | 120% | −97% |
Labels between years: 8% ↑ Inflation · 6% ↑ ″ · 4% ↓ Disinflation · 4% ↓ ″ · 12% ↑ Inflation · 23% ↓ Deflation (prices ↓ −ve).
Practice: monthly change in the general price level
| Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.0% | 2.6% | 0.9% | −0.5% | −1.2% | −0.2% | 2.1% | 2.6% | 4.1% | 3.8% | 3.6% | 3.5% |
Q: which periods show inflation? deflation? disinflation?
- Jan – Mar → Disinflation (still positive, falling)
- Apr – Jun → Deflation (negative)
- Jul – Sep → Inflation (rising)
- Oct – Dec → Disinflation (positive, falling)
| ★ Inflation → Prices ↑ | ★ Deflation → Prices ↓ (−ve) |
|---|---|
| Reasons: 1) AD ↑ 2) AS ↓ ⇒ shortage ⇒ prices ↑ | Reasons: 1) AD ↓ 2) AS ↑ ⇒ surplus ⇒ prices ↓ ⇒ deflation |
Inflation VS Deflation — the board's chains
| Inflation | Deflation |
|---|---|
| Prices ↑ → consumption ↓ → AD ↓ → surplus → prices ↓ (deflation) | Prices ↓ → consumption ↑ → AD ↑ → shortage → prices ↑ (inflation) |
| producer: production ↓ → DL ↓ → unemployment ↑ | producer: production ↑ → DL ↑ → unemployment ↓ |
| With deflation, X price ↓, M price ↑ (relatively inflation abroad) → X qty ↑, M qty ↓ → XTR ↑, MTE ↓ → C ↑ → AD ↑ → shortage → prices ↑ (inflation) | |
5. Policies to Deal with Inflation
Policies to deal with inflation (prices ↑) → Target: 1) AD ↓ → Demand-side policy → Fiscal / Monetary policy (reason: AD ↑) | 2) AS ↑ → Supply-side policy (reason: AS ↓)
★ Macro-economic objectives
- Price stability
- Full employment
- Economic growth
- Redistribution of income / wealth
- BOP stability
Demand-side policy → target: AD ↓ → surplus → prices ↓ → Contractionary fiscal / monetary policy.
Fiscal policy = part of demand-side policy; tools: taxation and government expenditure, manipulated to influence AD and achieve macro objectives.
A. Contractionary Fiscal Policy → target AD ↓
| Taxation ↑ | Government exp ↓ | |
|---|---|---|
| Income tax ↑ → disposable income ↓ → purchasing power ↓ → consumption ↓ → AD ↓ | Corporation tax ↑ → retained profits ↓ → reinvestment ↓ → investment exp ↓ → AD ↓ | Roads ↓ → jobs ↓ → income ↓ → C ↓ → AD ↓ → U ↑ |
AD ↓ → producer: production ↓ → DL ↓ → Unemployment ↑ → output ↓, GDP ↓, low economic growth.
Surplus: T.R > G.E
Deficit: G.E > T.R
Objective: price stability.
Conflict: full employment & economic growth.
P → P₁ ✓ but Y → Y₁ ⇒ output falls, unemployment ↑.
B. Contractionary Monetary Policy → target AD ↓
Monetary policy = part of demand-side policy; tools: money supply, interest rate, exchange rate, manipulated to influence AD.
| Money supply / interest rate (−ve) | Interest rate / exchange rate (+ve) |
|---|---|
| MS ↓, r ↑ savers: save ↑ (rate of return ↑) → spend ↓ → C ↓ → AD ↓ borrowers: borrow ↓ (cost of borrowing ↑) → reinvestment ↓ → I.E. ↓ → AD ↓ | r ↑, ER ↑ X price ↑, X qty ↓ → XTR ↓ → C ↓ → AD ↓ → U ↑ M price ↓, M qty ↑ → MTE ↑ ⇒ BOT deficit (MTE > XTR) |
AD ↓ → producer: production ↓ → DL ↓ → unemployment ↑ → output ↓, GDP ↓, low economic growth.
C. Supply-Side Policy → target AS ↑
Supply-side policy → target: AS ↑ → surplus → prices ↓ | SRAS ↑ and LRAS ↑ (potential ↑)
SRAS ↑ — reasons:
- Cost of production ↓
- Provision of subsidy
- Removal of indirect tax
- Prices of raw materials ↓
- Relocation of factory
- Grants / schemes
- Training / education to workers
- Privatisation
P ↓ → price stability ✓
Y ↑ → R.I. ↑ → purchasing power ↑ ⇒ full employment, economic growth ✓
Long-run AS ↑ (potential ↑)
LRAS ↑ → potential is increasing ⇒ PPC shifts outward. Reasons:
- Discovery of natural resources
- Technological advancement
- Immigration of workers
- Fall in price of energy
- Population / labour force ↑
- Quantity of capital goods ↑
| Gap between actual and potential starts to decrease | Actual reaches potential |
|---|---|
| surplus of resources → price ↓ → hyper → mild inflation | shortage of resources → price ↑ → hyper-inflation |
Hyper-inflation converted into mild inflation — a shift in potential shifts the LRAS curve (LRAS → LRAS₁), so real income can rise instead of only prices.
① Opportunity cost ② Costly ③ Long-term effect ④ Time-consuming
(money could have been spent elsewhere, e.g. subsidies or infrastructure; technology gives no immediate effect)
6. Policies to Deal with Deflation
Policies to deal with deflation (prices ↓; reasons: AD ↓, AS ↑) → target: 1) AD ↑ → Demand-side policy → Fiscal / Monetary policy (cost / expenditure)
A. Expansionary Fiscal Policy → target AD ↑
| Taxation ↓ | Government exp ↑ | |
|---|---|---|
| Income tax ↓ → disposable income ↑ → purchasing power ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑ | Corporation tax ↓ → retained profits ↑ → reinvestment ↑ → I.E. ↑ → AD ↑ | Roads ↑ → jobs ↑ → income ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑ → U ↓ |
AD ↑ → producer: production ↑ → DL ↑ → unemployment ↓ → output ↑, GDP ↑, economic growth ↑
| Short run | Long run |
|---|---|
| Multiplier effect (I, O, E ↑) → mild inflation: prices ↑ 10%, R.I. ↑ 50% | Hyper-inflation: only price ↑, R.I. constant |
Objective: full employment, economic growth.
Conflict: price stability — mild inflation first (P ↑10%, RI ↑50%), then hyper-inflation (P ↑50%, RI ↑10%, finally only P ↑).
B. Expansionary Monetary Policy → target AD ↑
| Money supply / interest rate (−ve) | Interest rate / exchange rate (+ve) |
|---|---|
| MS ↑, r ↓ savers: save ↓ (rate of return ↓) → spend ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑ borrowers: borrow ↑ (cost of borrowing ↓) → reinvestment ↑ → I.E. ↑ → AD ↑ | r ↓, ER ↓ X price ↓, X qty ↑ → XTR ↑ → C ↑ → AD ↑ → U ↓ M price ↑, M qty ↓ → MTE ↓ ⇒ BOT surplus (XTR > MTE) |
AD ↑ → producer: production ↑ → DL ↑ → unemployment ↓ → output ↑, GDP ↑, EG ↑. Short run: multiplier effect (I, O, E ↑) → mild inflation (P ↑10%, RI ↑50%); long run: hyper-inflation (P ↑, RI constant).
7. Quick Recap — Full Chapter Cheat-Sheet
- Inflation: persistent, sustained ↑ in general price level · Disinflation: prices ↑ at a slower rate · Deflation: persistent ↓ in prices
- AD = C + I + G + (X − M) · BOT = XTR − MTE (surplus XTR > MTE, deficit MTE > XTR)
- RI % = NI % − Inflation % · Real interest rate % = nominal interest % − inflation %
- Inflation reasons: AD ↑, AS ↓ (shortage) · Deflation reasons: AD ↓, AS ↑ (surplus)
- M.S and r → −ve · r and ER → +ve
- #1 unemployment ↑ · #2 BOT deficit · #3 depreciation · #4 real income ↓ · #5 savers (saving discouraged) · #6 lenders hurt, borrowers gain · #7 menu cost · #8 shoe-leather cost · #9 fixed-income / pension earners hit hardest
- Evaluation: anticipated vs unanticipated · internal vs external · exchange-rate system
- Cost-push (AS ↓): cost of production ↑, indirect tax, subsidy removed, raw materials ↑, imported inflation, wage-price spiral
- Monetary inflation: MS ↑ → r ↓ → AD ↑ → mild inflation (short run), hyper-inflation (long run)
- Inflation: contractionary fiscal (tax ↑, G ↓) / monetary (MS ↓, r ↑) → AD ↓ → price stability ✓ but unemployment ↑ ✗ · supply-side (SRAS ↑, LRAS ↑) → non-inflationary growth, but costly, slow, opportunity cost
- Deflation: expansionary fiscal (tax ↓, G ↑) / monetary (MS ↑, r ↓) → AD ↑ → full employment ✓ but hyper-inflation in long run ✗